Appreciate this article? +972 depends on your support -- click here to help us keep going

Analysis News

Don’t blame settlers for violence against Palestinians

Israeli soldiers are the ones who make the prolonged dispossession of the Palestinians possible. If the army wasn’t there, violent settler attacks could not take place.

By Yesh Din, written by Yossi Gurvitz

Border Police officer shaking hands with Israeli settler, March 2, 2013 (Guy, Ta’ayush activist)

One morning in late February of this year, J., a resident of a village in the Nablus district, went to work in his field along with his two cousins, M. and A. (We are not using the complainants’s full names for the same reason members of the Shin Bet are only known by a single name: the fear, perfectly justified in this case, that by exposing complainants’ names we will be putting them at risk). The three reached the field with a horse, a donkey, a chainsaw and various other tools. They worked for several hours, and at about noon were alarmed to see an armed mob approaching them, reportedly composed of Israeli citizens, coming from the direction of the settlement of Yitzhar.

The mob was composed of twenty to thirty settlers with their faces covered, accompanied by three or four soldiers. One of the soldiers pointed his gun at M. and demanded his ID card; J. and A. started to leave with their tools when they noticed the settlers beginning to break branches of the olive trees, their source of livelihood. J. started crying “thieves, thieves,” and begged the soldiers to do something to stop the damage.

Just 100 meters separated the settlers from the soldiers, and yet, according to the testimony, the soldiers stood idly by guarding the hoodlums and doing nothing to prevent the property damage. J. watched helplessly as the settlers stole his horse, his chainsaw, and his coat, which contained a very precious possession, his ID. “Look at these thieves,” said J to the soldier in desperation, “they are taking my things.” “Relax,” replied the soldier; “we’ll talk to the police.” M followed the settlers, who returned to the settlement. He noticed a settlement security vehicle, as well as a military jeep in close proximity. No one intervened.

This blog often deals with the depredations of the settlers, but it must be acknowledged that when all is said and done, it’s not their fault. The settlers who go out on “price tag” attacks strongly believe they have rights to the land and the Palestinians don’t, so they do not feel they are stealing from the Palestinians. The patron saint of religious Zionism, the convicted terrorist (Hebrew) and former Chief Rabbi Mordechai Eliahu, has given explicit permission to the settlers to loot the fruit of the labor of Palestinians (Hebrew); Other rabbis, such as the writers of the “Torat Ha’Melech” tract — incidentally, they too reside in Yitzhar — have gone further, permitting the bloodshed of Palestinians and their children (Hebrew). Why bother complaining about the Price Tag settlers? They don’t consider the Palestinians to be human and they don’t consider Israeli law, much less military law, as binding. The Talmud says that “it’s not the mouse that steals, it’s the hole”: if the mouse didn’t have a hole to run to, it would not steal.

There is a sovereign entity, or at least someone filling its shoes, in the West Bank; that sovereign entity is the IDF. And this sovereign body is not at all enthusiastic about enforcing the law of the land over the whims of the settlers. Generations of officers have learned from experience that enforcing the law can be a major hindrance to their careers. Soldiers have absorbed the lesson that there’s simply no point in trying to prevent the settlers’ raids. If they try to, they know that the military wing of the settlers – aka “a small number of fanatics over whom we have no control” – will make them pay the price. So the soldiers resign themselves to serving as the settlers’ violent backup, without which this reign of terror could not continue.

It’s unpleasant but it needs to be stated: the soldiers, or the power that comes from the barrel of a gun, are the ones that make the prolonged dispossession of the Palestinians possible. For a generation, the IDF continuously claimed it should be left out of the political debate, since it “does not choose its missions.” Apparently, one of the missions it has no choice but to carry out is escorting settlers on their vicious raids. And we all know that this is not an isolated incident.

Let it be known to every mother in Israel, let it be known to every Israeli taxpayer, that when it comes to the systematic dispossession of a poor, humiliated population, the IDF does not shirk its duty. Let it be clear, if the army wasn’t there, these incidents could not take place.

The image of a Palestinian farmer begging an apathetic soldier for the return of his chainsaw, his horse, his poor ID card without which he cannot live, as he is being robbed by gangsters, should be seen by every member of the Israeli civic community. We sent that soldier there. He is our emissary. He is doing what we, by action or inaction, ordered him to do.

The Israeli civic community? That’s assuming there is one.

Written by Yossi Gurvitz in his capacity as a blogger for Yesh Din, Volunteers for Human Rights. A version of this post was first published on Yesh Din’s blog.

For additional original analysis and breaking news, visit +972 Magazine's Facebook page or follow us on Twitter. Our newsletter features a comprehensive round-up of the week's events. Sign up here.

View article: AAA
Share article
Print article
  • COMMENTS

    1. aristeides

      Not to exculpate the soldiers, but there’s plenty of blame to place on the settlers, too.

      After all, what else is the typical IDF soldier but a settler in a uniform. 18 years, then you’d expect a sudden change?

      Reply to Comment
    2. directrob

      One could say nobody has a free will and we are all programmed by our genes and society. So nobody is guilty.

      In any normal definition of guilt and blame just about every 18+ year old Israeli is more or less guilty and to blame for what happens to the Palestinians. What is worse there is almost no excuse, Israel is not a totalitarian state like the DDR.

      To single out settlers as the ones most to blame is somewhat artificial (the government and the state support them) but to call them innocent is to put it mildly pushing it.

      Reply to Comment
    3. “The mob was composed of twenty to thirty settlers with their faces covered, accompanied by three or four soldiers.” : IDF soldiers are agents of the State. Settler action in the presense of protective IDF soldiers is State action. Thus the settlers have usurped State occupation policy–willingly so, from the Government and Knesset. There is no difference, operationally, between the settler and the State, and one should not expect resident Palestinians of the Bank to make such a distinction. Moreover, since the vanguard settlers apply a version of Torah ideology, that ideology attaches to the State. The State, in outcome, is directly religious.

      Reply to Comment
    4. Palestinan

      Cant we just blame both of them ,or maybe the their government ,or the people who support them and encourage their children to enroll in the army ? Is there a difference between a settler in Oranit and a settler in Yazur ?!

      Reply to Comment
    5. Dan

      Don’t blame the soldiers. It’s the government that either instructs or permits soldiers to defend settlers. Settlers and soldiers both carry out government policy. And who chose the government? The idiots of Israel.

      Reply to Comment
    6. rsgengland

      I have read this article a number of time, but can not seem to find any facts.
      Did the soldiers take the donkey, chain saw and id’s. If so, has it been reported or logged as fact by yesh din.
      There were vehicles there and soldiers there.
      Besides a lot of unsubstantiated allegations in the article, is there proof of any sort that this incident happened.
      Or is it propaganda of sorts, a little like the child killed in Gaza by an Israeli missile that most probably was a Palestinian missile that did not do as it was supposed to do.

      Reply to Comment
      • aristeides

        Big of you to accept that the child was actually killed, not a doll planted by the evil pallywood propaganda outlet.

        Reply to Comment
      • It is not necessary that the soldiers take anything. If they protect or support settlers who do take something, then the removal is an act of the State. To differentiate soldiers and settlers in such situations is a Kafka shell game.

        Reply to Comment
    7. The Trespasser

      >Let it be known to every mother in Israel, let it be known to every Israeli taxpayer, that when it comes to the systematic dispossession of a poor, humiliated population, the IDF does not shirk its duty. Let it be clear, if the army wasn’t there, these incidents could not take place.

      Sufficient is that every mother and every tax payer in Israel knows that Palestinians won’t stop at nothing to make Levant Juden-frei.

      Reply to Comment
    8. Romi Elnagar

      This is nonsense. The settlers are not children, are they? They are grown men who are responsible for their own actions. The IDF isn’t holding a gun to their heads and FORCING them to beat up Palestinians, are they? When a bank is robbed, you don’t blame the crime on the police who show up ten minutes later. When someone is murdered, you don’t blame the police who failed to arrest the murderer, even if he committed murders before. Unfortunately, I’m afraid a lot of Jews have gotten into the habit of blaming somebody else. If soldiers stand by and do nothing while settlers go on a rampage, it is STILL the fault of the SETTLERS for their mischief.
      The soldiers are accessories to the crimes, of course, but they are not the perpetrators.

      Reply to Comment
    9. ajamu chaminuka

      In the final analysis, the problem is the illegal political entity known as israel which was founded by european colonialism at the expense of the indigenous population who are to this day occupied,brutalized,and killed by this illegal colonialist state. For there to be justice, the Palestinians must be allowed to return and reclaim their lost homes and land and the state of israel must pay reparations before being dissolved.

      Reply to Comment

    LEAVE A COMMENT

    Name (Required)
    Mail (Required)
    Website
    Free text

© 2010 - 2014 +972 Magazine
Follow Us
Credits

+972 is an independent, blog-based web magazine. It was launched in August 2010, resulting from a merger of a number of popular English-language blogs dealing with life and politics in Israel and Palestine.

Website empowered by RSVP

Illustrations: Eran Mendel