Appreciate this article? +972 depends on your support -- click here to help us keep going

Analysis News

Did Romney snub Labor leader at PM Netanyahu's request?

Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has been accused of playing the American political game. It seems that his friend Mitt Romney is now involved in Israeli politics, having cancelled a meeting with Labor head Shelly Yachimovich at the last minute. Labor Minister: ‘Romney may have been misled by political players in Israel.’

Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and Republican nominee Mitt Romney, July 29 2012 (photo: Avi Ochayon/GPO)

A meeting between the Republican nominee and the Labor leader, Shelly Yachimovich, was cancelled last minute by Romney’s staff, despite having initiated it and repeatedly confirmed it until today. According to Haaretz, a probable reason for the cancellation was a request from Prime Minister Netanyahu, who sees Yachimovich as his biggest political rival today.

Romney will be meeting the prime minister twice during his short visit to Israel. During his first meeting (this morning), the leaders of Labor were informed by Romney’s staff that their own meeting was canceled. Some initial reports claimed that the cancellation was to make time for the nominee’s visit to the Western Wall today, but the visit to the Wall was planned and scheduled way ahead, and shouldn’t have interfered.

Protocol demands that official visits such as Romney’s include a meeting with the leader of the opposition, and Romney’s staff have explained the cancellation by the fact the Yachimovich no longer serves in that role (as Kadima leader Shaul Mofaz’s withdrawal from the government puts his party back in the opposition). However, Yachimovich’s staff did confirm the meeting with Romney’s people beforehand, and until the meeting with Netanyahu, Romney’s staff made it clear that they insist on conducting a photo-op and formal meeting with Yachomivch and Labor minister Herzog.

Romney did however meet with Kadima’s Shaul Mofaz, who has now regained his role as opposition leader.

Several people around Yachimovich told Haaretz that they believe it was the prime minister that requested from his old friend Mitt Romney to cancel the photo-op with the Labor leader, who has seen a rapid rise in the polls in recent weeks. According to this narrative, Romney’s meeting with the fragmented Kadima is no real problem for Netanyahu, but the last thing he wants is to upgrade Labor’s leaders to the level of statesmen.

This was the press release Labor issued this afternoon, stopping very short of openly accusing the Republican candidate of playing the local political game:

Labor parliamentary group leader M.K Isaac Herzog expresses regret at the surprising last minute cancellation of the meeting between U.S presidential candidate Mitt Romney and Labor Party Leader M.K Shelly Yachimovich and Herzog himself, a meeting which was initiated by Governors Romney;s staff. Herzog, who was coordinating the meeting, said he felt that Romney may have been misled by political players in Israel who are afraid of the consistent strengthening of Labor party leader Yachimovich and her becoming the clear alternative opposing Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu. Even though Romney headquarters knew during the coordination of the meeting that Yachimovitch was no longer serving as opposition leader, they kept the meeting and even published it details over the weekend. “It is a pity that Governor Romney did not have the opportunity to hear about the political and economical alternative that exists today to Netanyahu’s Government and that alternative is the Labor Party.”

There are indeed strong indications that Netanyahu sees a real threat in Yachimovich. Kadima has collapsed in the polls, and Yair Lapid is not gaining momentum. But recent hikes in taxes by Netanyahu and his flip-flopping on the national draft issue helped Labor gain momentum. The last poll, published this weekend, had only 10 seats between Likud (27) and Labor (another poll had Labor with more than 20 seats!). Netanyahu knows that if Yachimovich gains a few more seats, there will be a rush of voters from other left parties to Labor (as was the case with Kadima in the last election). From his point of view, this is the worst scenario possible.

Political blogger Tal Schneider recently noted an interesting detail: For the first time since Labor held their primaries, the prime minister office began attacking Yachimovich personally.

Update: Romney’s staff denies Netanyahu’s involvement in the cancellation of the meeting with Yechimovitz today. 

Read Also:
Romney uses Adelson’s free paper to criticize Obama
Jewish Democrats attack Romney from the (far) right

For additional original analysis and breaking news, visit +972 Magazine's Facebook page or follow us on Twitter. Our newsletter features a comprehensive round-up of the week's events. Sign up here.

View article: AAA
Share article
Print article
  • COMMENTS

    1. Prometheus

      Avoda is a dying horse. They have no viable platforma and have long discredited themselves.
      Not that Likud is any better – far from that, but there’s Bibi, who disregarding his personal or other qualities is not a stupid man, expirienced, rather well educated, known to the world.
      On ther hand Shely – an undergraduated journalist.
      What possibly she could know about running a country?
      If she is the best Avoda has to offer – this party is really dying. I find very hard to believe that every 5th Israeli is that stupid.

      Reply to Comment
    2. XYZ

      Shelli is the leader of a party with IIRC 8 seats in the Knesset. Compared with Mofaz’s 28 (his being the leader of the opposition), that is nothing.

      Reply to Comment
    3. Shimon

      A snub is a snub, simple as that. Truth be told however, a labor leader is not someone who Republican Mitt Romney would ideally like to meet. They are polar opposites on economic issues, and as for the peace process, well you can just forget about that. A good excuse to avoid that meeting (and avoda no longer being the official opposition is a decent one) was all he needed.
      Talk of Bibi’s intelligence and credentials means nothing to me, having enough knowledge on his father’s literary works it has become fairly obvious that he is indeed his father’s son. With cunning, intelligence and popular manipulation, he will attempt to replicate the nationalists of Europe and turn Israel into the very thing that made it a necessity in the first place.
      I’d rather have an inexperienced leader (if Yachimovich is that at all, a naive assumption) than an experienced and cunning leader who would lead the nation into the ground (an obvious biased opinion I’ll note, most however are likely ignorant of Bibi’s father, Benzion’s zionist philosophies and the similarities shared between those and Bibi’s).

      Reply to Comment

    LEAVE A COMMENT

    Name (Required)
    Mail (Required)
    Website
    Free text

© 2010 - 2014 +972 Magazine
Follow Us
Credits

+972 is an independent, blog-based web magazine. It was launched in August 2010, resulting from a merger of a number of popular English-language blogs dealing with life and politics in Israel and Palestine.

Website empowered by RSVP

Illustrations: Eran Mendel