Appreciate this article? +972 depends on your support -- click here to help us keep going

Analysis News

Collision course: Plan to displace tens of thousands of Bedouin passes first Knesset vote

The implementation of the Prawer Plan for unrecognized villages in the Negev has become a major policy objective for the Netanyahu government.

Riot Police face a Bedouin during an evacuation of the unrecognized village Al-Araqib (photo: Activestills)

Following one of the most heated debates the Israeli parliament has seen in recent years, the Knesset approved the Prawer-Begin Plan for the Arrangement of Bedouin-Palestinian Settlement in the Negev yesterday (Monday). Commonly referred to as the Prawer Plan, the new legislation will allow the government to destroy dozens of so-called “unrecognized” villages in the South and remove between 30-40,000 Bedouin from their homes.

According to the plan, those Bedouin citizens who have registered land claims will be offered monetary compensation or land in an area designated for resettlement.

Following demands from the right-wing Jewish Home party, a new article was added to the bill at the last minute, stipulating that the government’s compensation offer will expire after a certain period of time; failure to comply with the process will not only result in forced removal to the relocation zones but also a loss of monetary compensation or land, which would have previously been offered.

This is the largest attempted eviction of a native Palestinian population by Israel in decades. At the end of the process, all remaining Bedouin land claims will be erased from the state record.

During the Knesset debate, several Palestinian members of Knesset tore the bill before leaving the room. Due to opposition to the bill from the Right – settler groups object to giving any land rights to the Bedouin – none of the Likud ministers were willing to defend the bill in the name of the government. The offer ended up passing in a very narrow vote, 43-40, thanks to the support of Yair Lapid’s Yesh Atid party, which also sent one of its ministers to defend the law.

Destroying Palestinian villages while planning and building for Jews

The issue of the unrecognized villages, most of them in the South, has accompanied Israel since its inception. In the early 1950s, Israel refused to recognize the native Bedouin population’s claim to the land due to a lack of registration of the land by the British Mandate authorities (there are, however, records of permanent, non-nomadic Bedouin settlements going back to the 19th century). Other unrecognized villages are “temporary” settlements of Bedouins who were displaced in the 1948 War and were never allowed to return to their lands (after the war, Bedouin who lived in the western Negev were ordered to move east, and Jewish settlements were built in the area).

Over the years, Israel has built seven towns for the Bedouin and demanded that the population living in unrecognized villages relocate to them. Many preferred to stay in their villages, claiming that the townships are not suitable for their way of life, which is centered on agriculture and the use of farm animals.

Gradual recognition of the problem began in the 1970s when the government conducted a survey of Bedouin land claims. However, those claims weren’t recognized and more than 40 villages were defined as illegal, and were therefore deprived of government services. Petitions by Bedouin citizens to Israeli courts on the matter were rejected.

The Prawer-Begin bill is the result of a process that began in 2008 with the appointment of a national committee of inquiry into the issue of the unrecognized villages. The final plan will see most of the unrecognized villages destroyed, and some — mainly in the triangle between Ksseifa, Dimona and Beer Sheba — recognized by the state. A new bureau in the Prime Minister’s Office (PMO), led by former IDF General Doron Almog, will be in charge of the execution of the plan (Ehud Prawer, who gave the plan his name, is also a former IDF general who is now a senior executive in the PMO).

A Bedouin protest against the implementation of the Prawer Plan for the unrecognized villages, March 2012 (photo: Activestills.com)

The Bedouin leadership and civil and human rights groups reject the Prawer plan. They demand the villages be recognized and that the local population be included in the process of drafting new zoning plans. They also point to the fact that the government encourages Jews to move south, especially to agricultural settlements, all the while aiming to destroy Arab settlements that in some cases predate the creation of the state. The government is currently planning 10 new settlements for Jews in the Negev.

Supporters of the plan claim that it will benefit the vast majority of Bedouin by moving them to towns which will have better infrastructure and more employment opportunities than in the unrecognized villages. They point to the opposition of the extreme-Right as proof of the plan’s generosity towards the non-Jewish population.

A test for the government, Palestinian population

The Prawer Plan is becoming a major test for the determination of the government, on one hand, and of Palestinian citizens of Israel on the other. The Netanyahu government views the plan’s successful execution as one of its major policy objectives for this term. A large budget has been secured for the bureau tasked with its implementation and the proposed bill includes the creation of at least 250 new positions for personnel in the Israel Police’s Southern District.

Palestinian Knesset members and Bedouin leaders are promising resistance to the evacuation with all possible means, including seeking the involvement of international bodies and foreign states. Yet the crucial confrontation will take place on the ground, where things are still up in the air. It’s very hard to estimate the degree of resistance the Bedouin population will be able to demonstrate as the Prawer Plan is implemented. The project is planned to take place in stages, with the actual evacuation process taking place seperately in each area.

The Bedouins are the poorest, least organized of Israel’s non-Jewish citizens and public opinion seems hostile to them. In the past, they haven’t been able to mobilize in the way Palestinians in northern towns and cities in Israel have. The exception is the ongoing battle over the village of Al-Araqib, which was destroyed by Israel and rebuilt by local Bedouin over 40 times.

The Prawer-Begin bill will now be sent to the Knesset Interior Affairs and Environment Committee to be prepared for the second and third readings, which could take place as early as next month.

Related:
‘Algorithm of expropriation’: Plan to uproot 30,000 Bedouin
WATCH: The Israeli government’s plan to displace Bedouin
WATCH: Jewish settlers await destruction of Bedouin village in Negev

For additional original analysis and breaking news, visit +972 Magazine's Facebook page or follow us on Twitter. Our newsletter features a comprehensive round-up of the week's events. Sign up here.

View article: AAA
Share article
Print article
  • COMMENTS

    1. Forced relocation of prior residents was common in the US through most of the 1800′s. Part of Israel’s PR problem is that Western values have ostensibly changed from such times, while Israel sees itself as merely doing what all have done–with less net harm. Then, as now, the removed are already marginalized from socio-politics–which is the focus, these people refusing yet another denial of autonomy. The government will say that they will be better off if they do what the government wants. And so Jews coming to Israel have been told as well. But these Bedouin have been here all along; they did not come from elsewhere, asking for the embrace of Israel.

      Reply to Comment
    2. Sarah M

      The 2011 Ma’ariv article Noam links to has a key line: “לדבריו, בין צומת שוקת לערד אין ולא ישוב יהודי אחד ויש מקום לישובים יהודיים חדשים.”
      Between Tzomet Shoket and Arad is the historical Siyug, so its exactly where a lot of the threatened Bedouin villages are.

      Reply to Comment
    3. Monty Pogoda

      Examine the facts before you write rubbish>

      Reply to Comment
      • Gearoid

        Feel free to explain exactly which part is “rubbish”.

        Unless you mean the entire racist plan, in which case I agree.

        Reply to Comment
    4. aristeides

      There’s been some controversy in US Jewish circles recently over Kerry’s push to get US Jews behind a “peace process.” Dov Waxman in Haaretz had a more realistic view in his op-ed: US Jews don’t really care that much, and those who care tend to support the status quo.

      It’ll be interesting to see if this plan for an Arab Trail of Tears will shift opinion.

      Reply to Comment
    5. rsgengland

      It appears from this article that if the Muslim Israeli members of the Knesset had stayed to vote, the law would not have passed.
      The article does not mention the fact that a large percentage of illegal Bedouin settlements will be legalized.
      All the facts would help sometimes.

      Reply to Comment
    6. Khaled Khalid

      Israel Expelling 40,000 Bedoin from their homes –
      Is this what Robert De Niro meant by “Israelis need to be aggressive in their situation” ??

      If the situation were reversed it would be called Nazism.
      How many “Unrecognized” Shtetles were razed in Germany and Poland by Nazi Soldiers? Has Israel no shame or are we simply in the land of the Hypocrite?

      Reply to Comment
      • rsgengland

        Do not try to bring in the Nazis.
        When they shifted populations, it was to the gas chambers and crematoria.
        The Israeli Government is shifting a certain amount of Bedouin to a new village.
        THERE IS NO COMPARISON.
        Study some history.

        Reply to Comment
        • Eric

          The Bedouins can be erased as a distinct people relatively easily, mainly by detaching them from the lands they’ve lived on for centuries and in which much of their identity is vested. No need to send them to the gas chambers — just send in the IDF.

          But history will remember.

          Reply to Comment
    7. XYZ

      I always find Arab attempts to compare Israel to Nazis rather convoluted. Prof Sami Smooka’s recently released survey of Israeli Arab attitudes says 1/3 don’t believe there was a Holocaust. Also many other Arabs, including Abbas himsemlf are Holocaust deniers, so what does it mean when they compare Israel to Nazis..if indeed the Nazis didn’t do anything bad? Mein Kampf is a best seller in the Arab world, so if they think Nazism is bad, why would they find that book instructive. YOu must remember, the Arabs were basically only marginally involved in World War II and many hated the British and French colonizers, so they would naturally view “the enemy of my enemy is my friend”. Thus, Hitler and Nazism do not generate the same visceral response that those who suffered directly from it do. My theory is that the comparison of Israel to Nazism is due to the strong influence the USSR had on major Arab states like EGypt, Syria and Iraq decades ago and it is being repreated by inertia without the Arabs thinking too much about it.

      Reply to Comment
    8. Uri ZACKHEM

      When the Ottomans established Beersheba in the early 20th centurey, they paid for the land they used used to the owners – the ‘Azazme. So much for the backward Ottomans. To force the El’Uqbi tribe out of El’Araqib the Israeli govt. demolished the school (early 1950s). The Ottoman period school in Umm Batin was demolished by the Israeli military regime in the 1950s.
      The archeologist Dan Gazit reports that right after the occupation of Beersheba the archives in their entirety – that included all the land arrangements) were moved to the state archives and got lost there.
      We see a backward racist pirate state here. It is an ethnocracy as well. It does not matter if one’s Palestinian in Israel (with citizenship) or in the territories (without) as far as practice concerned you have no rights. Only the uebermenschen have rights.

      Reply to Comment

    LEAVE A COMMENT

    Name (Required)
    Mail (Required)
    Website
    Free text

© 2010 - 2014 +972 Magazine
Follow Us
Credits

+972 is an independent, blog-based web magazine. It was launched in August 2010, resulting from a merger of a number of popular English-language blogs dealing with life and politics in Israel and Palestine.

Website empowered by RSVP

Illustrations: Eran Mendel