Appreciate this article? +972 depends on your support -- click here to help us keep going

Analysis News

Blogger interrogated, asked to give up army source

The Israeli blogger ‘Eishton‘ has been questioned by civilian and military police in an attempt to make him reveal a whistleblower who supplied him with unclassified military documents. His interrogation has attracted media attention to the anonymous blogger and his writing.

Eishton (a combination of the Hebrew words for “newspaper’ and “man”) was interrogated by police in an attempt to push him into giving up a source within the army or the Ministry of Defense, who helped him in his unique in-depth three-part research on army casualties.

Following the interrogation, Eishton published a warning on his blog, stating that he is not allowed to discuss details of the investigation, “the aim of which is to silence, hurt and extract private and protected information in an attempt to incriminate me and others.” The blogger also warns that should his site go offline, it is probably be because he was pressured to censor information or give up sources. In a recent Facebook post Eishton also states that investigative authorities convinced the court to give them warrants to force internet companies to reveal his identity, and which have enabled invasive searches in his and his relatives’ homes.

The warning notice openning the blog. "Eishton is now under a joint interogation of CID and Israeli police!"

The warning notice opening the blog. “Eishton is now under a joint interrogation of CID and Israeli police!”

The research at the heart of the investigation was published last April, around Israel’s Memorial Day, and focused both on the lack of information regarding the circumstances of soldier deaths, and on the disproportionally large numbers of soldier suicides, as compared with civilian suicides. Eishton found out that while politicians and journalists were mourning the loss of 126 soldiers who had officially “died while protecting their country” between April 2011-2012 – the number of soldiers who had actually been killed in combat that year was no more than three. What about the rest? Eleven are actually civilians killed in terrorist attacks; 35 did not even pass during that year, but were retroactively recognized as “fallen soldiers”; and all the rest died from various other reasons, ranging from disease, to car crashes, to the number one cause of death in the army – suicide. Thanks to his source in the army or Ministry of Defense, Eishton discovered exactly how many soldiers had committed suicide, and how this was generally hidden by authorities. It is this source, who helped expose the real numbers and causes of death, who authorities are now trying to hunt down – and who Eishton is determined to protect.

The story of the interrogation has been covered widely by Israeli media, with some trying to make comparisons to the story of Uri Blau and Anat Kamm. Haaretz reporter Barak Ravid was the first to write about it in his blog, and followed up on the story with the help of his colleague Amos Harel. IDF sources confirmed that an investigation was under way by the Criminal Investigation Division, as as “bereaved families told the IDF that details of the circumstances surrounding their sons’ deaths were published on the Internet, based on what appeared to be ‘slain persons reports,’ internal military reports that document the investigations into deaths of soldiers.”

Ravid himself was interviewed on Channel 10 last night, and expressed the belief that had Eishton been a recognized journalist, authorities would not have dared to try and breach the confidentiality of his source. Moshe Negbi, one of Israel’s leading authorities on journalism and law, said, however, that the problem lies with the fact that Israel has no laws protecting journalists’ sources, and that judicial rulings on the matter have always left whistleblowers within the security apparatus as an exception to journalistic immunity, without any protection.

Other journalists took on Eishton’s challenge, and started digging into causes of soldiers’ deaths and the question of suicides, yet it seems that so far none have managed to match Eishton’s thoroughness. He has commented on some of these reports in his latest post, which was translated in part and published on Ravid’s blog.

The only known picture of Eishton, made especially by the blogger for Zman Tel Aviv (Eishton)

The only known picture of Eishton, made especially by the blogger for Zman Tel Aviv (Eishton)

Who is Eishton?

One of the amazing things about this story is that no one, aside from the police, has any idea who Eishton is. In fact, I am the only journalist known to have ever interviewed him, and I too don’t know who he his. His posts reveal a person of left-wing politics, but who is highly critical of his own political camp, as well as of mainstream media, which he blames for many of society’s illnesses. In the interview that I conducted with him via e-mail, and which was published in Zman Tel Aviv (Ma’ariv’s local supplement) in July, the blogger revealed that he used to work in jobs that brought him “six figure sums,” but that he now focuses mainly on his blog, which takes up most his time, energy and financial resources. Eishton asks readers to contribute if they like his writing to support his work.

After the interview was heavily edited and massively cut down in the paper (to my great regret) Eishton published the full version (Hebrew) of it on his blog, stating he would never give an interview again. Eishton was fair enough to say that the problem was not with his interviewer, but with the way the media industry “simply deletes whatever doesn’t conform to the picture they wish to paint.”

The IDF and the police spokesperson unit did not respond to questions sent to them by +972. Eishton has also refused all interviews this week, but stated on his homepage that he might consider offering a single interview to one specific (unnamed) publication.

For additional original analysis and breaking news, visit +972 Magazine's Facebook page or follow us on Twitter. Our newsletter features a comprehensive round-up of the week's events. Sign up here.

View article: AAA
Share article
Print article
  • COMMENTS

    1. So? What is the number of deaths by suicide?

      Reply to Comment
    2. “Following the interrogation, Eishton published a warning on his blog, stating that he is not allowed to discuss details of the investigation, ‘the aim of which is to silence, hurt and extract private and protected information in an attempt to incriminate me and others.’ The blogger also warns that should his site go offline, it is probably be because he was pressured to censor information or give up sources.”

      The Kol ha-Am opinion of 1953 (Agranat writing for a unanimous 3 member panel) places a high bar on press censorship. The Court held that the right of personal liberty is incorporated into Israel via English common law through the Mandate. If Eishton has been treated as press by other presses (which you detail he has), he should be considered press (if the State can define press then Kol ha-Am is effectively gutted); harassment to the point of shut down, given the general stand of journalist source protection, is equivalent to an administrative ban, which is what the 1953 case overturned. Pnina Lahav in Judgment in Jerusalem (1997) notes:

      “it is quite clear that when the petition came before the Court, the justices were well aware that the government viewed the suspension as a necessary means of defending Israel’s reputation abroad and preventing social disruption at home” (p. 108; see, generally, pp. 107-12).

      The case described herein is clearly of less danger to the State or society. The IDF wants to find the leak and is preasuring Eishton to the point of (he) removing his blog; this is similar to a journalist staying in jail rather than reveal his source. Such jailings, in the US, need greater motivation than hiding the number of suicides in the army; pending danger, or criminal conspiracy, is required (if Eishton paid for his information, things change…). Keeping a journalist from his job is a form of shutting down the press. If Eishton can no longer function at his blog under the norms he has previously established, similar to those employed by journalists, his shutting down of the blog, for that reason, is State removal of a press.

      Crucially, Israeli press has already treated his blog as a plausible source; socially, his blog has been defined as a member of the press by that press, before State action. However, his anonimity is not sheilded as the owner/agent of the press. He cannot claim the status of a journalist if anonymous, nor make a claim as owner of a blog treated as a press if so.

      Lahav, cited above, describes Agranat’s thinking in Kol ha-Am thus:

      “considerations shaping the contours of rights are not confined to collectivist or utilitarian calculations. The self-realization of individuals and their role as political actors constitute an integral political value…It is imperative for the State to facilitate open deliberation, albeit distasteful, because open deliberation is an important part of the moral value of the State itself.” (p. 109, above)

      Agranat also imported the Declaration of Independence as a normative consideration; I think it should be imported as a constitutional document.

      If the IDF/State press on, I think any argument for legal protection will force Eishton to reveal himself, and rightly so: usually, when declaring defense by right, one must place oneself open for inspection.

      I have thought for some time that the battle for an Israeli constitutional jurispurdence of rights would start from attacks on the left. Maybe this is one.

      Take care, journalist.

      Reply to Comment
    3. Arieh

      Israel’s Julian Asagne?

      Reply to Comment
    4. Suicide is rife within all armies and he o brass don’t give a flying hoo haa.

      Reply to Comment

    LEAVE A COMMENT

    Name (Required)
    Mail (Required)
    Website
    Free text

© 2010 - 2014 +972 Magazine
Follow Us
Credits

+972 is an independent, blog-based web magazine. It was launched in August 2010, resulting from a merger of a number of popular English-language blogs dealing with life and politics in Israel and Palestine.

Website empowered by RSVP

Illustrations: Eran Mendel