Appreciate this article? +972 depends on your support -- click here to help us keep going

Analysis News

Block by block, Egyptians fight their past for a new future

‘For me, today is one of the days of the revolution,’ Egyptian poet Zain El-Abdeen Fouad says, describing the recent unrest as part of a process of a continuing social transformation. ‘The [revolt against Mubarak] sparked the revolution and it never ended. The revolution will continue until it achieves its goals.’

By Jesse Rosenfeld

Clashes dissipate on Cairo’s Mohammad Mahmoud Street, January 25, 2013 (Photo: Jesse Rosenfeld)

CAIRO – Walking through Cairo’s Munira neighborhood on the third day of clashes since the second anniversary of Egypt’s revolution, riot cops sit behind barbwire awaiting protesters’ return following a night of clashes.

Just blocks from Tahrir Square and the U.S. and British Embassies, the neighborhood is increasingly looking like the old Baghdad Green Zone, with concrete walls carving up downtown Cairo and blocking routes between Tahrir, government ministries and foreign missions. Regular clashes between thousands of protesters and police have raged at the end of my block as the death toll across the country mounts. The teargas lingers in the towering apartment-lined side streets long after everyone has dispersed.

I returned to Cairo on the afternoon of the 25th as hundreds of thousands gathered in Tahrir Square to air their discontent at a stalled revolution that has yet to fulfill demands of freedom, dignity and social justice. Riots raged on the fringes of Liberation Square; youth on Mohammad Mahmud Street hurled rocks over a towering concrete barrier at security forces guarding the Parliament. In a display reminiscent of anti-wall demonstrations in the occupied West Bank, security forces responded with volleys of tear gas fired over the concrete blocks, temporarily clearing the street under a suffocating white cloud.

But the driving force behind the discontent in Egypt is not the same as in Palestine, or Iraq under the Americans. The rage here emanates from a political tug-of-war, fought out in the streets, between the legacy of the authoritarian, elitist politics of the Mubarak regime and popular demands for rights and real inclusion in the new Egypt.

“For me, today is one of the days of the revolution,” Egyptian poet Zain El-Abdeen Fouad tells me on January 25, in a packed, narrow alley filled with shisha cafés sprawling into the streets near Tahrir. As demonstrations swirl around the adjacent blocks, he describes the anniversary of the revolution not as a memorialization of what has changed, but as another day in the process of a continuing social transformation. Fouad is a poet of the Arab street and contends that the artists out with him today are the beginnings of a cultural revolution. As he speaks, Fouad is regularly interrupted by protesters stopping by to wish him well.

For Fouad, the main success of bringing down Mubarak has been the psychological transformation of Egyptians. Fear of publicly engaging in politics has collapsed and a sense of grassroots transformation of the state and society is taking hold.

Yet, the reality of looming IMF-imposed austerity – that will end much-needed state subsidies of food and fuel – threatens to derail the revolution’s demand of social justice through economic redistribution. Meanwhile, December’s constitutional referendum on amendments pushed by President Morsi and passed amidst mass boycotts enshrined a legal process of military trials for civilians, increased the influence of Islam over the state, put limits on political freedoms and made no reference to workers’ or women’s rights, setting the tone for the continued use of Mubarak-era top-down politics of exclusion to rule the country.

“We cannot achieve everything in one day,” Fouad contends. “The [revolt against Mubarak] sparked the revolution and it never ended. The revolution will continue ‘till it achieves its goals.”

A protester on the edge of Cairo’s Tahrir Square, January 26, 2013 (Photo: Jesse Rosenfeld)

His sentiments are evident in city streets across Egypt as protests rage, days on from January 25. Outrage increases along with the death toll and social divisions are emerging over the Port Said verdict, condemning to death 21 local Ultras over a February 2012 soccer riot, in which at least 79 people were killed. Still, no verdict has been issued for those members of the security forces accused of being involved. Much of the anger in Port Said is directed at security forces, who are seen as scapegoating the soccer rioters in order to avoid their showing their own complicity.

In Cairo, protesters have been targeting the Ministry of Interior (the hated symbol of Mubarak-era authoritarian power) and the Shura Council (Egypt’s upper house of parliament dealing with the constitution) resurrecting the 2011 chant, “the people want the downfall of the regime,” this time in reference to Morsi.

The downtown of Egypt’s capital has turned into a maze of concrete and chaos. Wandering through the city center trying to find a route home on Saturday evening, I attempt to duck down empty side streets only to realize that they are so filled with tear gas that I’m forced to stagger back towards the center of Tahrir for a breath of normal Cairo air.

Taking another route out of the square I run into masses of youth on The October 6 Bridge and Corniche setting fires and hurling stones and Molotov cocktails at police, who in turn, blanket the area in vast clouds of tear gas. Nonetheless, there are few places for me to go as my roommate sends word that my street is also blocked off because of intense clashes.

So I watch as young people in Guy Fawkes masks and the balaclavas of the newly declared ‘Cairo black bloc’ fight with the police. For an uprising that inspired anti-austerity movements in Europe and Occupy in the US, it seems only fitting that the black bloc – a new force in Egypt’s street protests – would emerge as the emblem of a 21st century revolutionary city. But whether they are actually anarchists or just importing Western protest aesthetics is difficult to discern as many refuse to talk to journalists, myself included, about what they believe.

As the anniversary of the 2011 revolution continues and memories of how far people have come are contrasted with the realization of how far they may need to go, the legacy of the old regime compounds with the current crisis and disillusionment. Cairo is a city where the street is fighting block by block for demands of the revolution amidst the realization that if it doesn’t, the Egyptian state could revert into a new form of its old self. In a country where – as the documentary about Clash lead singer Joe Strummer is titled – the future is unwritten, this is a struggle between where Egyptians have come from and where they are going.

Jesse Rosenfeld is a Canadian journalist based between Ramallah, Tel Aviv and Cairo. Covering politics, war and social upheaval, he has published with The Nation, The Guardian, The Irish Times, Le Monde Diplomatique, The National and The Toronto Star, among others. He tweets at @jrosyfield.

For additional original analysis and breaking news, visit +972 Magazine's Facebook page or follow us on Twitter. Our newsletter features a comprehensive round-up of the week's events. Sign up here.

View article: AAA
Share article
Print article
  • COMMENTS

    1. JKNoReally

      I suppose it was inevitable that the guy who made a Jew-baiting video about drunk morons, in coordination with another guy who’s a pet monkey for PressTV, would end up on 972+. Really scraping the bottom of the barrel with Mr. Rosenfeld fellas.

      Reply to Comment
    2. XYZ

      Here, once again, we see the “progressives” expressing their dream of an uprising of the “masses” that will end up the bringing to power of people who will make a society of “social justice” and “economic redistribution”.
      But, right there, we see the seeds of the failure of this “progressive” dream.
      Who says a government has a right to redestribute wealth? Simply because someone is smarter and more innovative, the “masses” have the right to come and take away him money? Since when is jealousy grounds for theft? I know, I know, good Marxists will tell you that all personal wealth is made by “exploitation” of the workers, but has it ever occurred to them that if it weren’t for this capitalist, they would be sitting at home in poverty?
      The government indeed has an obligation to see to it that those who don’t have the basic minimum to live on get this, but their job is to see that the economy grows so that ALL prosper, NOT to see that everyone is the same. That leads to Soviet-style stagnation and corruption. Because if the “progressive” is going to redistribute wealth, he will set up a committee to do so, and first of all, he will give to himself and his friends and in the end, the masses will suffer most. Just read George Orwell’s “Animal Farm” to see how this really works.

      Reply to Comment
    3. Kolumn9

      And Egypt continues to circle the drain as the progressives cheer the next glorious revolution that will establish paradise on earth for the workers.

      Reply to Comment
    4. Charles-Jerusalem

      Good morning,
      Me I would say that the Egyptians governement will go on fucking up until the Egyptian army takes over saying that democraty has done enough damage to Egypt.

      Reply to Comment
    5. Vittorio

      TO AMI KAUFMAN WHO WON’T PUBLISH THIS POST ON HIS BLOG:

      That’s nice. The dream bit. Most of us love motherhood and apple pie. But some people are orphans and others can’t easily get apple pies.

      What would be interesting is to know how do you suppose you could achieve your dream of

      “Equality and justice for all between the river and the sea.”

      Are you sure the Arabs would grant equality to Jews if they get the reins? They didn’t in the past, you do know that?

      AMI: YOU ARE AN INTELLECTUAL COWARD. AND YOU KNOW IT.

      Reply to Comment

    LEAVE A COMMENT

    Name (Required)
    Mail (Required)
    Website
    Free text

© 2010 - 2014 +972 Magazine
Follow Us
Credits

+972 is an independent, blog-based web magazine. It was launched in August 2010, resulting from a merger of a number of popular English-language blogs dealing with life and politics in Israel and Palestine.

Website empowered by RSVP

Illustrations: Eran Mendel