Analysis News

Exclusive: Obama's response to Romney's 'cherished relations' ad

+972 has managed to get its hands onto a draft plan of President Barack Obama’s next campaign move,  hitting back at Mitt Romney after the latter unilaterally elevated the U.S. relationship with Israel from “special” to “cherished.”

According to the leaked document, the move will consist of a similar ad, elevating the relationship further to “precious.” Visual materials in the ad are rumoured to include tank-shaped chocolates, flowers and close-up shots on Obama’s doctoral degree from Yale. Alongside the ad, an automated phone campaign will be launched, bestowing upon each Jewish and evangelical household in the United States a message recorded by the president himself. The script for the message, also obtained by +972, runs as follows:

View article: AAA
Share article

Soldier girl's note to Bibi goes viral

One of the most odious features of the bi-annual budget approved by the cabinet last week and slated for an upcoming Knesset vote is the tax hike for the middle class (including a one-point increase in both VAT  and income tax for anyone earning a dime above the average monthly wage of  $2,100), contrasted with a ludicrous one-off $7 billion tax break for several huge multinationals. The note below, posted by a young IDF female soldier named Sapir Bachar on Netanyahu’s Facebook wall, garnered nearly 80,000 “likes” – a huge number in Israeli terms. It’s a very good illustration of just how absurd the situation of the Israeli middle class has become:

Hi Bibi,

I’m a conscript soldier, 19 years old, from Kfar Saba. I’m writing to you on Facebook since this is the only place I can express myself, as I’m banned by law from taking part in demonstrations. Most of my childhood memories mingle with flashbacks of loud fights between my mom and my dad over money, savings, the household, gas money and so on. I’m sure your kids never had to watch you and your wife fight over money. Anyway, their relationship was ruined and dad left the house when I was seven years old. This is when my childhood ends. Since then, my mother has worked morning and overnight shifts and studied for her first degree simultaneously. She didn’t have time to take care of us so I fed, washed and watched over my little brothers, did homework with them and broke up their fights. Since age 14 I’ve worked to support myself, to be able to go out once in a while, buy a shirt every now and then, buy a cellphone and save up money for a trip to Poland or a driver’s license. Yes, it was either-or. Today I’m a 19-year-old soldier, I still don’t have a driver’s license, and since my monthly soldier paycheck is $89, I also need to work weekends for a humiliating minimum wage. When I come home in the evening I still have house chores because my mom is working so hard, for so many hours. I’d say it’s worth it if it wasn’t for the fact you tax her for 40 percent of her salary. Yes, Bibi, nearly half of the time she’s working each month is going down...

Read More
View article: AAA
Share article

While you weren't looking: Jaw-dropping tax cut to tycoons

The front page of Israel’s main financial daily, The Marker, pretty much says all you need to know about the capital-government-military relationship in 2012 Israel:

Top headline: “They earned 120 billion – and will only pay  3 billion in taxes. A new proposal from the treasury to the tycoon companies increases tax break to 70 percent.”

Second headline: “Costs of gas rig security soars: The IDF demands 3 billion.”

The context here is that some of the largest companies operating in Israel have around NIS 120 billion worth of profits “stuck” inside the country: they haven’t registered the profits as dividends, so as not to pay corporate taxes, which would have amounted to about NIS 30 billion. The government is, as always, concerned about hurting their tender feelings and “scaring off investors”, so it’s bending over backwards to let them get away with as much as possible: The treasury originally demanded 25 billion, then the tax authority said 15 billion would be enough, then the finance minister, Yuval Steinitz, went down to 5 billion, and today, climbed down further, to 3 billion (and possibly as laughably little as 1 billion).

Meanwhile, the navy is asking for up to NIS 3 billion (for among other things,  acquiring four new warships) to do what the navy is supposed to do, which is to protect Israeli interests at sea. Only the interests, in this case, are not so much Israeli as Israel’s tycoons, who will be pocketing the vast majority of the profits from the gas fields. The previous estimate for the costs the state will incur in securing the rigs stood at NIS 20 million, and the commander of the navy told The Marker no more than three months ago that all the infrastructure for securing the gas fields was already in place.

In other words: Instead of gathering the actual taxes owed by tycoons – 20 billion or so – Israel agrees to take just 3 billion, and, literally on the same day, is required to pump these 3 billion back to the tycoons in the form of security for their gas rigs. What goes around comes around, and quickly, too.

View article: AAA
Share article

Olmert ruling: On princes and minions

Ehud Olmert, one of the erstwhile “princes” of the old Likud, was convicted today of breach of trust and acquitted on more serious charges of corruption in two cases, Rishon Tours and the Talansky money envelopes. Somehow, this seems apt: breach of trust is a term that might well be used to sum up the entire legacy of a prime minister who was elected as a ‘centrist’ committed to the ‘peace process’ or at least (perish the thought) to unilateral withdrawals, and proceeded to squander thousands of lives – Palestinians, Israelis, Lebanese – in two atrociously unnecessary wars.

Fortunately, we don’t yet have to deal with the  scenario of Israel’s worst-ever prime minister returning from the netherworld: The most serious and complicated case against Olmert, that of the Holyland apartment complex in Jerusalem, is still outstanding, and even if acquitted, Olmert is held in such contempt by most Israelis (largely for his disastrous mismanagement of the Second Lebanon War), the chances of him returning to power are blissfully slim.

But there’s one detail of the ruling I’d like to turn your attention to: While Olmert was acquitted, his principal assistant and secretary, Shula Zaken, who supposedly served as the go-between in the alleged bribe money transfers, was convicted. Among other things, of fraud. Yet the person on whose behalf she committed fraud, walks scot-free. Jupiter and oxen much?

At any rate, this is as good a day as any to reflect on the two most visible monuments to Olmert’s legacy: The separation wall and the Holyland project. The thousands of people who would have been alive if it wasn’t for him – Israelis, Palestinians, Lebanese – are, as usual, off-frame.

Photo: Dimi Reider

View article: AAA
Share article

How much does Israeli security know about any random passersby?

Call it a postcard from Putin, if you will: The account below was posted by Gil Yardeni, one of my favourite Israeli poets and a Hebrew University biology major, who happened to be passing by the visiting Russian president’s convoy in Jerusalem, a few hours ago. The weirdest thing about the whole affair is that leaving out the odd demonstration here and there, Gil can hardly be even considered an activist, much less a high-profile one. She doesn’t organise protests, she’s not member of any movement or party, and does not work for a human rights NGO. That the secret service (whatever branch that was) would have so much information available on her, and would be happy to flaunt it on the preposterous pretext of crossing the street in proximity to Putin’s convoy,  is nauseating. Here goes:

I was coming back from Tel Aviv thinking of all the things I like about Jerusalem. I fell asleep on the bus, and took the no.32 from the central bus station. It was held on Agrippas Street for 25 minutes. Then, when we got to Gaza Street, it turned out it was blocked. The passengers started a ruckus and the irate driver began driving around, looking for alternative route. He went up Jabotinsky, but the roundabout by President House was blocked. I asked to get off the bus and continued on foot.

It was hot, and late, and I have an exam on Wednedsday, so I was in a rush. I was walking quickly and when the VIP police convoy was driving by, I saw there are some gaps between them and crossed the road. I tried calling my boyfriend but my battery died, the Android rebooted itself, and I was trying to revive it as I walked.

On Harlap Street I was stopped by a man in a buttoned shirt. I thought at first he was a heckler, because he was speaking very slowly, but then he showed me a card and said I was detained. He asked for an ID card and requested that I show him what I have in my backpack and my binder – a Mearshemier article, a Gilfin article and my score sheet. “Why are you studying international relations,” he asked, and I started explaining it was an introductory course before I realised he knew what I was studying. He asked about  who my...

Read More
View article: AAA
Share article

Robert Conquest interview to pro-Bibi tabloid raises questions

Veteran Yediot Ahronoth reporter Sever Plocker published the following account on his Facebook page earlier tonight:

Professor Robert Conquest is one of the greatest living historians. He earned undying fame with the publication of his book on Stalin’s purges, “The Great Terror.” Last week, after a shameful delay, he got a kind of recognition from Israel: The Dan David award.

I asked for an interview. The organizers were glad and promised it’ll be exclusive. I asked after his health and was told it’s “not great”, but that an interview won’t be a problem. After the ceremony I felt somewhat doubtful and asked them again. They made inquiries and came back with with an affirmative.  They then asked if I’d be angry if Prof. Conquest also met a journalist from Yisrael Hayom, who wishes to write on the historian’s literary works. This wouldn’t be an interview, the organizers stressed. I’m not sensitive about the exclusivity issue, and I agreed.

On the morning of the interview I heard Prof. Conquest cancelled a lecture at the university because he “slipped in the bath.” I was once again soothed by the organizers that the interview will take place. I came to his hotel room and met a 95-year-old wreck of a man. I won’t elaborate: I sat before him for close to an hour with an open notebook, asked questions and couldn’t get a single clear sentence out of him. The professor would try speaking quietly and  immediately slip into an intricate, unique world of his own, looking for phrases, events and names. I’m not ashamed to admit I was close to tears. I made my goodbyes knowing I don’t have an interview, but that I’ve done a kind of a service to a great intellectual.

To my surprise, I read in the Friday issue of Yisrael Hayom a long, detailed interview with Professor Conquest. Not just any interview: The elderly professor told Yisrael Hayom everything Yisrael Hayom wanted to hear. That Israel is right on everything, that it’s good it annexed the Golan Heights, that its fears of Iran are justified, and so on and so forth. Two pages of an interview. I read and felt shamed: Despite my several decades in journalism, I failed in my attempt to interview Professor Conquest – and Yisrael Hayom succeeded. The very, very ill professor who, in his meeting with me couldn’t put...

Read More
View article: AAA
Share article

Journalist Uri Blau to stand trial for holding leaked documents

Attorney General Yehuda Weinstein announced on Wednesday his intention to indict Uri Blau, one of Israel’s top investigative reporters, for possession of classified materials without permission. The materials in question are documents given to Blau by whistleblower Anat Kamm; Kamm, then a conscript clerk in the office of GOC Central Command, copied them from the GOC’s computer, believing they constituted evidence of war crimes carried out in defiance of international law and Israel’s own Supreme Court, including summary executions of terrorism suspects who could have been detained.

Kamm is presently serving a four and a half-year prison sentence following a plea bargain in which she admitted to possession and transfer of classified documents.

The decision today marks a crucial milestone in a process that has been dragging on for more than two years, as prosecutors considered the implications of indicting a journalist for doing something well established in his trade. Almost every journalist with claims to be anything but a stenographer for the army spokesman has held onto classified information – written or otherwise – that was received outside official channels, without authorisation.

Although Blau, in the early days of the investigation into the leak, had already given over to the state all the documents he used to publish the story on summary executions, the state demanded the rest of the cache. During the investigation, Blau spent time in political exile in London, waiting while his lawyers negotiated with the state the terms of a deal under which he would not be prosecuted. Once the deal was struck and Blau did his part, however, the state got greedy, and demanded full access his entire archive, amassed over a decade of investigative work. Then it said it might prosecute him anyway. Blau remained in limbo, his ability to work severely curtailed: few sources would go out on a limb for a journalist likely to be tightly monitored by the security agencies. He only began writing regularly a few months ago, publishing a few stories on the behind the scenes workings of the Israeli right, mostly through deft use of freedom of information requests.

Obtaining and retaining classified information is the bread-and-butter of a civilian journalists monitoring the country’s most powerful and insulated institution – the military. Although Israel has no laws to protect journalists, in most cases (barring one prosecution concerning the revelation of cooperation between the Israeli and Morrocan intelligence agencies half...

Read More
View article: AAA
Share article

African kids in Tel Aviv: They'll do to us what they did to Jews in Germany

Following up on Noam’s report on what’s developing into a night of unprecedented violence against African asylum seekers in Tel Aviv, here is a testimony uploaded onto Facebook after yesterday’s protest, by one of the many community activists who walked home a group of African children to make sure they weren’t attacked.

I accompanied a group of asylum-seeking children to their homes tonight, as we always do on the days of protests with potential racist developments. As usual, we got barraged with swearwords, but policemen advised us about safer routes. The kids sang along the way: “I’m a nigger, I’m a nigger, nigger, and I clean Israeli homes” (“What, you don’t know it, Rami? Look it up on Youtube.) Two 12-year-old girls asked me if I know that pretty soon the Sudanese will suffer the same fate as Jews did in Germany. One asked the other to tell her about that man, Korczak, who saved children. They asked if he was Jewish and if he would have saved all the children. One girl asked me: “What’s the opposite of free?” I had trouble finding the word: imprisoned? shackled? She said: “Ok, whatever is is, say shackled, we were born shackled and we’ll die shackled.” The girls asked me why the Israelis want to deport them. I asked them: If the streets in your country would suddenly fill up with white people that speak in a language you don’t understand, what wold you feel? One girl said: “I’d become a teacher and teach them my language!” Toward the end two 12-year-old girls asked me: “Say, Rami, if you were in our place, what would you have done?”

 

View article: AAA
Share article

Revealed: Arab cabbies banned from driving BG Airport staff

Turns out that the Arab cab driver – any Israeli cab driver who happens to be Arab – is deemed so much a security risk simply by virtue of his excessive Arabness that he can’t be allowed to drive staff to and from Ben Gurion Airport. We learn this from an urgent letter sent today by the Association for Civil Rights Israel (ACRI), to the director of the Israel Airport Authority, Yaakov Ganot, demanding he cancel forthwith a directive issued from the office of the director of Ben Gurion Airport to a cab company servicing the employees of Israel’s main international hub.

The directive, signed by the airport’s transportation director Shuki Shemer, quite simply bans the company from employing “drivers from minorities, including all routes.” Palestinian citizens of Israel  are commonly referred to as “minorities”, a euphemism comparable in sophistication to using “coloureds” instead of “blacks” in American discourse.  The letter (Hebrew, .pdf) is so refreshingly blunt in its unmitigated racism it merits a full translation, with loving preservation of the officious clumsiness of the original:

30 April 2012

To: Moni Siton Transportation LTD

RE: Employee transportation 

Complaints have been recently received from members of the security and border control staff concerning the employment of drivers from minorities along the Jerusalem route, Malcha Cabs and Yisrael Cabs.

According to a decision by the director of the security department, you should not employ drivers from minorities, including all routes.

Regards,

Shuki Shemer

 

ACRI’s attorney Tal Hassin stressed (Hebrew) that the directive is illegal, being in explicit violation the Basic (constitutional) Law on Freedom of Occupation and the law on equality of opportunity in employment. I can only add to that that the IAA and Ben Gurion Airport are not private companies but state authorities. As Noam often says, if you don’t like the word “apartheid”, you’re welcome come up with a new term that will describe our situation with all its precious exceptionality – and nefariousness – thrown in.

 

View article: AAA
Share article

War trauma, kid? Not if you're Asian

The weekend supplement of Ma’ariv ran an exhaustive investigation of the effect the Palestinian rocket threat has on Israeli children living within their range. On the left is the “illustration” by one Ophir Bagon, which opened the story. On the right is the original photo. See the difference?

And here is the pic as it first appeared, on Ma’ariv’s front page just two months ago:

h/t John Brown 

View article: AAA
Share article

Yes, it is Cairo that's come to Montreal

The stray winds of the Internet brought to my desk the following piece by Rex Murphy. It doesn’t add much (anything) new to the debate, but it does offer a rather neat digest of a pseudo-liberal argument; the argument used by conservative commentators who enjoy applauding distant Middle Easterners fighting to find a voice, but quickly get cold feet when the same struggle erupts a little closer to home.

Serious protests, involving grave issues, with real risks and real moral purpose, are going on all over the world. They match life-and-death risk with the value of what is at stake: the human rights of citizens suffering under dictatorial governments. We can only hope that the eyes of the demonstrators in Syria don’t get the news of the tantrum going on in democratic Quebec… What’s going on in Quebec is not a protest. It’s a parody of one: the future elite of Quebec having a self-indulgent fit… Let’s just hope that no one in Syria has been paying attention.

Look: It doesn’t matter that in Cairo the original rallying flag was protesting a dictatorship, in Montreal – tuition fees and in Tel Aviv, originally, rent. Quebec, Wall Street, London, Tel Aviv, Madrid, Cairo, Tunisia, Syria, Bahrain are all part of the same Spring, because in all those cases multitudes of people are realising that it’s not that they are apolitical, but that the political system in their countries is inadequate at safeguarding and expressing their interests. That each system is geared primarily to preserve the status quo, and that status quo no longer tolerable, and needs to and can be overthrown. So someone sneeringly comparing “future elites having a self-indulgent fit” to the Brave Egyptians or the Fearless Syrians isn’t supporting the Arab Revolution. He’s merely revealing what side he is really on, and, whatever plaudits he pays revolutions happening at a safe distance, what side he would probably be in any other place the Spring has visited: The side of the status quo.

View article: AAA
Share article

Exclusive: 'Political contract' required to enter Israel?

A Swedish tourist trying to enter Israel was made to sign a “contract” promising she won’t get in touch with “pro-Palestinian” organisations, and acknowledging she’ll get deported if she “gets caught doing even one of these things.” Meanwhile, Prime Minister’s Office released a letter that will be handed to deported Flytilla activists: Go to Syria. 

Check this out. This is a “contract” that a Swedish citizen was required to sign upon entering Israel via the Eilat land crossing:

Please, stop snickering at the “nine-tens,” the “passpot,” and the bizarre grammatical construct in the first sentence. This is quite serious. The person in question told +972:

I’ve been in East Jerusalem on and off for six months now, visiting friends. Since I am here on a tourist visa, I have to leave the country every three months and renew my visa at the border. No problem, until this time when me and a friend made an Easter trip to Jordan and planned to get a new visa stamp in my passport on our way back. I’ll go back to Sweden next week again, so I just need a visa for my last days here.

When we got to the Israeli section of the border crossing – that one between Aqaba and Eilat – we were asked to sit down and wait a moment while they kept my passport. Then I was invited into an office and was questioned about my religion, if I had contact with any religious organizations here, what I do during the day, how much money I have got to spend and where I got it, what I do in Sweden and so on. Then we had to wait again, not knowing what would happen. After 4 hours and 20 minutes, I was asked to sign this contract and got back my passport with visa stamp in which the expiration date (normally three months later) was corrected to April 19, which is when I have my plane ticket home. Then we could finally enter Israel again.

They retained the original “contract” at the border control, and mine is only a copy. I don’t know what consequences I could expect if I would break it. Personally, I am pleased that I was let in and can spend...

Read More
View article: AAA
Share article

Labor: Netanyahu's many Facebook fans are not from Israel

Earlier this morning, the office of Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu posted this uncharacteristically laconic message:

The smug announcement was further drilled home by a press release from the Prime Minister’s Office, which gushed at the prime minister surpassing the 200,000 “likes” bar, noted opponents trail “far behind” and crowned the prime minister’s Facebook page as an instrument “linking the people and the leader.” The website of Labor leader Shelly Yachimovich (with a self-confessedly humble 20,000 plus ‘”likes”) quickly shot back with the following observation from the head of its Internet volunteer teams, Amichai Saragovi:

Saragovi then takes the gloves off and proceeds to accuse Netanyahu of deliberately misleading the public.

Screenshot of the searches can be found at the bottom of Saragovi’s post. It should be noted that Netanyahu has been advertising his page relentlessly in the last few months – even if none of the “likes” on his page have been purchased, as activists were quick to suggest, the financial investment in the page is a considerable one.

The Prime Minister’s Office is yet to respond to the stats.

 

View article: AAA
Share article
© 2010 - 2013 +972 Magazine
Follow Us
Credits

+972 is an independent, blog-based web magazine. It was launched in August 2010, resulting from a merger of a number of popular English-language blogs dealing with life and politics in Israel and Palestine.

Website empowered by RSVP

Illustrations: Eran Menedl


theme_function.php-begin | 19.893976MBtheme_function.php-end | 21.753744MBmost_stuff_widget_begin | 24.005584MBmost_stuff_widget_end | 24.551648MBtwitter_widget_begin | 24.560864MBtwitter_widget_end | 24.560864MBtheme_footer_before_end | 24.567816MB