Appreciate this article? +972 depends on your support -- click here to help us keep going

Analysis News

Gay? Girl? Damascus? Plot thickens around Syrian blogger

On Monday, this blog was one of the first to spread the world of the abduction of Syrian blogger Amina Abdallah Arraf, author of A Gay Girl in Damascus. A post on AGGID, purportedly written by Arraf’s cousin Rania Ismail, reported that two men bundled Amina into a car with a pro-regime sticker. A few hours later, a new post appeared, reporting there was no progress in the search for Amina. Then the blog went silent.

Come Thursday, however, very little remains of the stark and gripping tale that spread around the globe only a few days earlier. Try hard as they might, no journalist, diplomat or activist turned up anyone who met Amina in person. Despite her alleged double US-Syrian citizenship, no family members have made contact with State Department to plead for her case, even after the American consulate in Damascus took the unusual step of commenting on her blog and requesting family members to come forward. Even the woman described by many outlets as Amina’s girlfriend admitted she never met her in real life, and a day later the activist group with whom Amina was supposed to be meeting when she was abducted said it never met her nor knew anybody who did. The final blow was delivered by Londoner Jelena Lecic, who announced, through a publicist, that all of the photos of Amina released to date were her own.

Yesterday it was still tempting to look for holes and cracks in the Lecic story: No new photos were released by the publicist who initially spoke to the media, Kim Grahame of Just News International; the Just News International agency had only the most rudimentary of websites, a rather modest conduct for a PR company and in dissonance with its boastful motto of “servicing the world 24/7″; neither Grahame nor JNI had any web presence whatsoever outside the Amina affair; the agency’s owner and Grahame’s partner (according to Facebook), Julius Just, had recently befriended Lecic on the social networking website; and so on and so forth. All this gave ground to at least a vague suspicion the whole thing might be a black-op carried out by hired guns on behest of the Syrian regime, a kind of an extrovert take on the harrowing moment in Orwell’s 1984 when the torturer tells the dissident, “you do not exist”. But last night, Lecic appeared on Newsnight; and it’s become quite impossible, within the realm of sanity, to deny that the Amina photos were Lecic’s indeed.

So who is who? Is Amina, in fact, the devoutly dressed and actively pro-LGBT rights Rania Ismail? Peering over the borders of said realms of sanity, is she, concievably, Lecic after all? Is she a Syrian or pro-Syrian activist studying in the University of Edinburgh, to which an email exchange of hers has been traced? (As a side note, most Syrian activists use proxy servers; it’s not for nothing that when the Assad regime opened up Youtube and Facebook as the Arab Spring rumbled toward Syria, it also banned searches of the word “proxy.”)

My colleague Yuval Ben-Ami offers on his blog his own experience of hunting down the real people behind a suddenly vanished Internet persona – although the setting was nowhere near as dramatic and the stakes were nowhere near as high. He concludes with the following sentiment, which I can’t help but echo myself:

This is my secret hope: that whoever is responsible for this blog is safe and sound, and has simply put together the final text (written by a “cousin” of Arraf, who also doesn’t seem to exist) as a way of staying safe. I pray that everything written on this blog was true, except the word “girl” and that last, scary post. Finally, if it makes things easier for “Amina”, I pray that we will never find out who she was.

And for myself, I would just add that the shock of Amina’s disappearance yanked us out of what has become a routine – a ghastly routine, but a routine nonetheless – of indeterminate clashes and massacres coming out of Syria. It seems fairly plain that the fate of the Arab Spring, at least for this round, will be decided not in Libya- where it became a much less appealing civil war – but in Syria. The slow, lacklustre response of the international to Assad’s butchering of his own people  may well mean that the Arab Spring will stop at the Damascus gates. The energy and outrage generated by Amina’s story, be it true or not, need to be used to apply popular pressure to Syrian embassies and business interests around the world: Not just for the safe release of the blogger, whoever he or she or they may be, but for the resignation of the Assad regime.

For additional original analysis and breaking news, visit +972 Magazine's Facebook page or follow us on Twitter. Our newsletter features a comprehensive round-up of the week's events. Sign up here.

View article: AAA
Share article
Print article
  • COMMENTS

    1. Ales

      This article demonstrates how people want to continue to believe in something what they support, no matter what reality is. In this case, reality is very likely to be a fake story of one of Syria’s regime activists. It’s a perfect story. Good looking girl to sympathize with. Sexuality. Bravery. Sentiment. And at the end, the message someone wanted to push through: All of these shining parts accompanied with struggle against regime.

      And make no mistakes, both side lies in this Syria story.

      What annoys me is shameless fabrication using people emotions. People that support shiny ideals are deceived badly, probably by professionals.

      Reply to Comment
    2. lablueyz

      Dimi et al.,
      .
      At the risk of being greedy with bandwidth, I’m reposting my comments from YB-A’s story:
      .
      .
      “…
      ..While your gender-bending theory holds weight there is a darker scenario.
      .
      This _could_ be a composite of a cellular revolutionary movement.
      Why would such a group put someone (albeit in another country) in so much risk when there is the option of photoshop/qwark/etc.?
      .
      Government operated mouse trap seems more likely It allows data collection both internally and from contacts outs of Syria who may be cracked for yet more intel”
      .
      An affaire with a Book.face.
      Is the woman in m’real stupid or at the service of Syrian Intelligence?
      Either, the road prolly leads to a digustingly obese generally typing with one hand.

      ~lb*/
      “The only person I know who didn’t link to that phoney site.”

      Reply to Comment
    3. max

      The world cared about Amina Abdallah Arraf because she had a name and a face and gay to top it, so it wasn’t just another X people killed by this or that regime.
      Now that she lost both face and name, who cares?

      Reply to Comment
    4. Yonatan

      Remember Gulf War I? One story that came out that swung people against Saddam Hussein – his troops stole incubators for babies from a hospital in Kuwait. Oh the outrage! Hussein is a monster, the new Hitler! Except of course he didn’t steal the incubators. It was a marketing ploy by Rendon Group designed to sell the war. The woman (girl?) making the claim turned out to be linked to the Kuwait ruling mob. The ploy itself originated in WWI

      Something stinks about ths story. Look for similar stories that help market other wars.

      Reply to Comment
    5. sh

      The reason people read the blog is because it was written well. If whoever it is writes a book, I’m sure it’ll be a good read and sell well at airports.

      Reply to Comment
    6. lablueyz

      Yoni
      .
      Thank you!!! No one recalls, but that girl was a princess in the ruking family (.kw).
      .
      She was not in .kw during the any part of the ‘invasion’* but in the So. France with the rest of the royal family.
      .
      * the ambassador to Iraq, Alice XsomethingX gave Hussein GB!’s blessing to invade .kw (YES, he first asked permission.).
      .
      Somewhere in the archives of I believe the NYTimes resides a photo of that meeting.

      Reply to Comment
    7. nana

      It makes me sad that some people now are doubting what’s happening in Syria, because of this fiction by Amina.. let me tell you something.. Syria is real.. the horrific acts commited there are real.. AMINA.. is the only thing that is not real.. and whoever created her wanted people to doubt the Syrian news that are leaked.. pleeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeesase don’t!

      Reply to Comment
    8. Louise

      Hello from Edinburgh! The site which apparently first highlighted Amina Arraf as a blogger http://lezgetreal.com/2011/06/an-apology-to-our-readers-about-amina-abdallah/

      has now published her IPs. They do indeed trace back to the Edinburgh University broadband provider Keycom, but also if you google the 188.74.110.134 one, it leads you to some wikipedia editing and one of the topics concerns an incident at the University of Edinburgh where Ishmael Khaldi gave a talk to the J Soc http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Talk:Ishmael_Khaldi

      She also appears to have an Edinburgh dating profile with a fake Jelena Lecic profile pic and another one http://www.areyouinterested.com/singles/amina51256395397/101347744/profile.html

      I do wonder if this person is posting from a few streets away from me…

      Reply to Comment
    9. annie

      louise, very interesting. thanks for the links. especially the wiki talk editing link.

      i’m w/yonatan, “marketing ploy by Rendon Group designed to sell the war” sounds about right.

      Reply to Comment

    LEAVE A COMMENT

    Name (Required)
    Mail (Required)
    Website
    Free text

© 2010 - 2014 +972 Magazine
Follow Us
Credits

+972 is an independent, blog-based web magazine. It was launched in August 2010, resulting from a merger of a number of popular English-language blogs dealing with life and politics in Israel and Palestine.

Website empowered by RSVP

Illustrations: Eran Mendel